Thinking vs Feeling: Decoding the Mind-Body Connection

photo of Tampa psychotherapist, Leah Benson, LMHC with the words, "thinking and feeling are 2 very different things...?"
scribble depicting the sun

Understanding the dynamic between thinking vs feeling is essential for adults who prioritize self-care but question whether they’re grappling with clinical depression or anxiety. Often, what seems like a mental health disorder may stem from metabolic imbalances rather than a pathological condition. By prioritizing sleep, nutrition, physical movement, community connection, and healthy beliefs, many mental health challenges can be effectively resolved.

Feeling: The Body’s Ongoing Signal

Feelings, or moods, are constant, shaping our daily experience even when unnoticed. Based on the theory of constructed emotion, feelings arise from interoceptionyour brain’s representation of all sensations from internal organs, tissues, hormones, and the immune system. This ongoing feedback creates a spectrum of basic feelings, ranging from pleasant to unpleasant and calm to energized.

This spectrum can be mapped in a circumplex model of affect (aka mood). The horizontal axis represents valence (unpleasant to pleasant), while the vertical axis reflects arousal (highly energized to calm). Interoception shapes every thought and emotion, it is the origin of feeling. For instance, lack of sleep or excessive caffeine can alter your feelings, influencing your mental state.

depiction of a graph known as the Circumplex of Affect

Thinking: An Intersection of Mind and Body

While thinking vs feeling may be phenomenologically distinct, the line blurs upon closer inspection. Your mind is a combination of sensory signals your brain receives from your body, your past experiences, and your current context. Recall times when clear thinking was difficult—perhaps during illness, a heated argument, or after intense physical activity. In these moments, your body’s signals dominate your attention, impacting decisions and giving your mind the data it needs to construct an instance of emotion.

This interconnectedness underscores why mental clarity is supported by physical health. A body out of balance—due to poor sleep, inadequate nutrition, or lack of movement—can cloud thinking and intensify feelings of unease.

Reframing Depression and Anxiety

Depression and anxiety are often quickly labeled as disorders without examining underlying causes. Yet, these experiences may reflect metabolic imbalances rather than inherent psychopathology. Consider these factors:

  • Sleep: Insufficient rest can mimic depressive symptoms, like low energy or poor focus.
  • Nutrition: Diets lacking key nutrients can present as impaired cognitive functioning.
  • Movement: Regular physical activity bolsters cognitive resilience and clarity.
  • Community: Social isolation can amplify anxiety and depression.
  • Beliefs: Negative thought patterns can reinforce unhealthy habits.

By addressing these elements, many individuals find their symptoms improve without medical intervention. Thinking vs feeling serves as a framework to assess whether your mental state reflects lifestyle imbalances rather than a clinical condition.

Take the Next Step

If you’re wondering whether your mood signals depression, anxiety, or something else, a holistic approach can provide clarity. By examining thinking vs feeling in this new way and refining your lifestyle, you can restore balance and mental clarity.

Ready to do something about it?

Ready to understand how thinking vs feeling affects your mental health? Contact me today for a consultation. We’ll identify practical steps to enhance your well-being.

Leah Benson Therapy icon
The Feel Good Formula™
Ask me about The Feel Good Formula®

Share this article

Get your anger under control today with an experienced anger management counselor.

REQUEST A FREE COPY OF THE INTRODUCTION OF

EMOTIONAL UTOPIA

Just tell me who you are...

leah benson on mobile phone zoom meeting

Online
Therapy
Available

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to browse on this website, you accept the use of cookies for the above purposes.